The Great Dog Food Debate
While choosing a dog food used to be a simpler decision, dog owners today face a dizzying array of choices. They have to consider the costs and benefits of dry dog food vs wet dog food vs fresh dog food and more when deciding what’s right for their pup. With so many options and dog food myths circulating online, how do you know what’s best for your pet? The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. The best dog food depends on your dog’s individual needs, your lifestyle, and your budget.
Understanding Traditional Dog Food
Traditional dog food includes both dry (kibble) and wet varieties. Both have their unique benefits – and we encourage dog owners considering Merrick dog food to learn more about what our dry recipes and wet recipes bring to your pet’s bowl. No matter what you choose, you can feel confident that all Merrick recipes are formulated to be complete and balanced and meet AAFCO standards, which ensure your dog gets all the essential nutrients they need to thrive in just the right ratios. 
  
      
  
  
Benefits of Dry Dog Food
- Convenience & Shelf Stability: Easy to store, measure, and transport; long shelf life.
 
- Cost-Effectiveness: Fresh dog food vs kibble cost is a common concern – kibble is generally more affordable.
 
- Nutritional Completeness: High-quality kibble is complete and balanced dog food.
 
- Portion Control: Easy to manage calorie intake.
 
Is Kibble Bad for Dogs?
With many myths circulating around kibble, some dog parents wonder: Is dry dog food good for dogs? And the answer is: absolutely – when you choose complete and balanced dog food from reputable brands. Quality matters, and premium kibble, like Merrick’s, is made with real ingredients and rigorous safety standards. Science-backed formulations set high-quality kibble apart. Discover more about the care we put into our Merrick dry recipes here.
Benefits of Wet Dog Food
- Healthy Hydration: Moisture content in dog food is highest in wet varieties, supporting healthy hydration.
 
- Easier to Chew: Great for dogs with dental issues.
 
- Exceptional Palatability: Wet food appeals to picky eaters with its aroma and texture.
 
- Mealtime Variety: Wet recipes provide some variety in your pet’s diet and a complement to the texture of dry food. 
 
  
      
  
  
Exploring Fresh Dog Food
Is fresh dog food good for dogs? When formulated by experts to include the right vitamins, minerals, and nutrients, the answer is yes! Fresh and fresh frozen dog food options have become increasingly popular among dog owners in recent years for a few key reasons.  
- Excellent Palatability: Dogs love the taste and texture of fresh food.  
 
- Healthy Hydration: Like wet food, fresh food contains more moisture than kibble.  
 
- Ingredient Transparency: You’ll recognize all the main ingredients on the label.  
 
- Sensitivity-Friendly Options: Limited ingredient recipes made with single source proteins can be beneficial for dogs with sensitivities.  
 
We dive deeper into the benefits of fresh and fresh frozen dog food in this article.
Fresh Dog Food vs Kibble
Fresh dog food vs kibble is a hot topic. Fresh food is highly palatable and may suit picky eaters, while kibble offers convenience and affordability. Across dog foods, an ingredients comparison shows that fresh food often uses fewer, more recognizable ingredients. But a high-quality kibble can offer a similar ingredient profile. Ultimately, it all comes down to you and your pup’s unique needs! 
  
      
  
  
Can You Feed Fresh & Dry?
Absolutely! Mixed feeding – topping kibble with fresh or fresh frozen food – combines the benefits of dry dog food and fresh food. This approach offers convenience, cost-effectiveness, and excellent palatability. Just be sure to check the feeding instructions to avoid overfeeding.
Differences Between Fresh & Fresh Frozen Dog Food
Fresh frozen dog food, like Merrick Fresh Selects, is frozen immediately after cooking to maintain a mouth-watering texture and extend shelf life. It shares all the benefits of fresh food – high-quality ingredients, gentle cooking, and complete nutrition – but adds convenience.  
  
      
  
  
Making the Right Choice for Your Dog
Need some tips for how to choose a dog food? Consider your dog’s age, activity level, breed size, health conditions, palatability preferences (AKA selectiveness), and your own lifestyle and budget. Veterinary recommended dog food may include kibble, wet, or fresh options depending on your dog’s needs.  
For puppies, check out our article on choosing the best food for your puppy. And for dogs with special dietary needs, read about the potential benefits of healthy grains in a dog’s diet and explore the importance of omega fatty acids.
Merrick’s Commitment to Quality Nutrition
Merrick’s philosophy centers on high-quality ingredients, real meat first, and no artificial flavors or preservatives. Whether you choose kibble, wet food, or Fresh Selects, Merrick prioritizes complete and balanced dog food crafted to meet AAFCO standards. Explore all our nourishing dog food recipes.
Conclusion: Informed Choices for a Healthy, Happy Dog
High-quality kibble, wet food, and fresh frozen food can all provide excellent nutrition. The best dog food for dogs is the one that meets your dog’s individual needs and fits your lifestyle. With knowledge and confidence, you can make the right choice for your furry friend. And remember, if you’re considering switching foods, be sure to follow recommended guidelines for changing your dog’s food.
For more expert tips on dog food myths and how to choose a dog food, explore our full library of Merrick articles.